Who Can We Trust About Seed Oils?
First, we do know that greed drives many people and oftentimes corrupts the data that we rely upon to know what’s true. In the case of seed oils we have three main groups of people who have controlled the narrative:
- Companies that sell these products
- The government that regulates these products and
- Scientists who research these products
Companies who create these products do so to sell at a profit. Unfortunately, the truth is that most companies highlight good information and delete the bad information so that their product is seen in the best light possible leading to higher sales, greater esteem from colleagues and a more comfortable life.
Companies like Proctor & Gamble and Archer Daniels are Fortune 500 companies that spend millions each year on marketing, lobbyists and lawyers to ensure that they come out on top. Both of these companies have specific interest in ensuring that seed oils are seen in a good light.
But…this works both ways.
Much smaller companies like Zero Acre Farms or influencers like Dr. Paul Saladino and Dr. Eric Berg are on the opposite side of the coin and work to show how dangerous seed oils are. The problem is that they also have a vested interest in creating a narrative that will cause people to buy what they are selling. This might be a supplement, beef tallow, a book or even just getting you to subscribe to their channel.
Interestingly, even Dr. Saladino when he is questioned a little bit admits that something as simple as not overeating and maintaining a proper caloric diet may mitigate the concern caused by seed oils and high levels of linoleic acid.
It's difficult to know who is telling the truth and who we can trust, and it’s also difficult at times to know if the scientific research was done well and whether it tells the right story. Was the cohort large enough? Did it follow the subjects for a long enough time? Were they looking at the right markers? How did funding or relationships with lobbyists influence the results? We could go on and on.
Both sides highlight studies that support their narrative and point out how the other side is skewing the data, however, there are a lot more studies that seem to indicate that replacing some of our saturated fats with unsaturated fats from vegetable oils is warranted.
But personally, I don't know if I buy that narrative and I'm not so sure that the plethora of studies isn't a result of the early marketing and lobbying from companies like Proctor & Gamble.